Eagle Eye’s case study of Tesco Clubcard Challenges reports 76% of distinct visitors to the challenge pages became players. Of the players, 62% reached their first reward. [1] Those percentages describe different steps, with different groups underneath each calculation.
The case covers personalized shopping challenges run in six-week campaigns during 2024. The fourth campaign targeted 10 million Clubcard members in the UK. Targeted members, page visitors and players are separate populations.
| Measure | Reported figure | Population |
|---|---|---|
| Members targeted | 10 million | Fourth UK campaign |
| Became players | 76% | Distinct visitors to challenge pages |
| Reached first reward | 62% | Players |
A first reward earned is also different from a reward redeemed. Using the 62% figure as a redemption target for your whole member base would change both the behavior and the population being measured.
Read the measure before borrowing the percentage. If members rarely start, investigate access and relevance. If they start but rarely qualify, examine the required behavior. If they qualify but rarely redeem, review the reward and redemption steps.
Give members equal time to act
Tesco’s six-week campaign period matters when comparing results. For your own rewards, also allow customers equal time to redeem. Someone receiving a reward on the final day has had less time than someone receiving one three months earlier.
Before comparing rates, ask each team to state the denominator and observation period. Use equivalent eligibility and timing rules. A change in either alters the result even when customer behavior stays the same.
Check whose behavior the research describes
Mando and YouGov’s Understanding Loyalty in Europe 4.0 overview reports 63% of adults across 24 European markets belong to at least one loyalty program. [2]
Joining any program is a different outcome from joining your program. The figure therefore does not establish a participation target for an individual retailer.
Deloitte’s survey covered 5,564 US adult loyalty members. Several questions, including behavioral impact and redemption, concerned respondents’ preferred program in an assigned industry. The publisher cautions against applying those findings across all memberships. [3]
Your entire member base includes occasional and inactive members. Deloitte’s preferred-program responses do not represent all those relationships.
Match the business context
Look for a comparable market, sector, purchase cycle and program maturity. A weekly purchase gives customers different opportunities from an annual purchase. A newly launched program also has a different member mix from an established one.
Then check the method. Recalled behavior in a survey and recorded transactions provide different evidence. Both are useful, but combining them into a single ranking hides the distinction.
Check collection dates as well as publication dates. A report published this year might describe an earlier period.
When a missing definition prevents a fair comparison, use the finding as context. A target needs a measure the team understands and a reason the comparison fits the business.
Set targets against your own baseline
For first purchases, group members by joining period and give each group equal time to buy. Establish this baseline before judging an onboarding change. A recent group with less time to purchase will otherwise appear weaker by design.
With a reliable baseline, link the target to a proposed change. If you revise onboarding, state the expected improvement, measure and review period.
Put the population, definition, observation period and method beside each benchmark in the management presentation. Then name the change expected to improve your own result. This gives the team something to test when the next review comes around.
References
[1] Eagle Eye. Tesco Clubcard Challenges case study. Results from the 2024 campaigns. Accessed 31 October 2026. View source
[2] Mando and YouGov. Understanding Loyalty in Europe 4.0. Publisher overview, 2026. View source
[3] Deloitte. Reshaping loyalty programs in an era of value seeking. 12 January 2026. Survey methodology and endnote 4. View source